top of page

⚡ Module 10 — The Revaluation of All Values | Nietzsche Course

Nov 11
15 min read

Updated: 2 days ago

Help us reach the people who may need this most by sharing this free course with friends, family, colleagues, online communities, social media or on your own website.


⚡ Module 10 — The Revaluation of All Values


🎧 Read By Audio – Listen on the Go - (coming soon)


The lesson on the death of God ended on an image: a door swung open onto an empty sky, and a danger waiting on the far side of it. That danger has a name, and it is the thing most people actually dread when they hear that the old certainties are gone. If nothing underwrites right and wrong any longer, if there is no cosmic author signing off on what matters, then does everything simply slide into meaninglessness? Is there anything left to care about at all? The fear is not paranoia. Nietzsche thought it was the defining crisis of the age arriving. What he did not think is that it was the end of the story. He treated it as a passage, terrible and necessary, on the way to the thing he cared about more than any of his famous demolitions, the deliberate creation of new values by human beings for a world that has to make its own meaning now. That project was the point of the wrecking ball all along.


Today we're exploring the revaluation of all values, the constructive heart of Nietzsche's philosophy and the mission he set for his entire late period. Where most of his famous ideas tear something down, this one builds. To reach it the lesson first walks all the way into nihilism, named and defined in the lesson on the death of God and anatomized here in full. By the end it should be clear why nihilism arrives in two opposite forms wearing one name, why the loss of an absolute foundation for values looks at first like a catastrophe, and why Nietzsche made the reverse move and called it the beginning of the most serious work human beings have ever been handed. And because this course has been quietly assembling a dossier for exactly this moment, the lesson ends with its biggest tool: a full method for putting a value on trial, reaching a verdict, and, for the first time, signing one's name to the result.



Nihilism: The Room Behind the Door


The lesson on the death of God gave nihilism its definition in one line: the state in which the highest values lose their value and the question why finds no answer. It then set the condition aside for later, and this is later. What that lesson could only name, this one takes apart, because the definition hides a mechanism, and the mechanism is what makes the room so hard to leave.


For centuries, Nietzsche argues, Western life organized itself around a set of supreme values, truth, goodness, and the God who guaranteed them, a real purpose woven into the order of things. When the foundation under those values gives way, the values do not vanish overnight. They linger, but they lose their grip, and a terrible question opens beneath them. Why be good at all, what makes truth worth seeking, where is the reason to keep going, once the thing that made those answers absolute is gone. Nihilism is what fills the silence when that question finds no reply. It is the sense of an existence with no aim, nothing finally worth reaching for, and caring itself left suspended over empty air.


Nietzsche did not treat this as one gloomy opinion among others, the kind of thing a person argues themselves into on a bad night. He treated it as a historical event, a sickness a whole civilization catches when its old values die faster than it can grow new ones. He thought it was coming for Europe with the force of a tide, and he cast himself as the physician who had spotted it early. What he wrote of himself in his notebooks, that he was the first perfect nihilist of Europe, one who had already lived nihilism through to its end and left it behind him, was not a boast about despair. It was a claim to have walked into the room ahead of everyone else and found the way out.



Passive and Active Nihilism


Nietzsche draws a distinction inside nihilism that is easy to miss and completely decisive, because it splits the condition into two opposite things wearing the same name.


Passive Nihilism


This is nihilism as a symptom of exhaustion, the form that surfaces when a spirit no longer has the strength to create. Faced with the collapse of meaning, it gives up the search, sinks into weariness, and reaches for whatever will dull the ache: comfort, distraction, numbness, rest at any price. It shrugs, says that nothing matters anyway, and quietly takes that as permission to stop trying. There is a familiar modern version, the person who decided somewhere along the line that nothing much matters and built a life around never having to feel it, hours of easy distraction, every large question kept at arm's length. Nietzsche feared this form most, because from the inside it does not register as a crisis. It feels like relief, and it wears the face of the Last Man from the lesson on the Übermensch, the small, cozy creature who has stopped longing for anything higher and calls his comfort happiness. Passive nihilism does not rage against the loss of meaning. It settles in and pulls a blanket over its head.


Active Nihilism


This is nihilism as a sign of rising strength, and it behaves in the opposite way. The active nihilist looks at the exhausted old values, sees that they are hollow, and instead of sinking he attacks. He takes a hammer to what is no longer believable and tears it down on purpose, clearing the ground by force. This is still destruction, and Nietzsche never pretends otherwise, but it is destruction with a future folded inside it, the violent housecleaning that has to happen before anything can be built on the site. The roaring lion from the three metamorphoses, the spirit that says its sacred No to inherited duty and wins the freedom to create, is active nihilism in motion. It cannot yet make new values. It can do the necessary work of clearing the dead ones away.

Everything, for Nietzsche, hangs on which form wins out. Passive nihilism ends in a contented, meaningless smallness, a civilization that has stopped reaching and no longer notices that it has stopped. Active nihilism is dangerous, but it can be passed through, because it is a beginning disguised as an ending. Nietzsche never wanted humanity to make its peace with nihilism. He wanted it to go all the way into the room and out the other side, building something new on the cleared ground.



Created Values and No Absolute Ground


How does a person, or a culture, get out the far side? Nietzsche's answer is the revaluation of all values, and to see why it counts as an answer rather than a surrender, two discoveries from earlier in the course have to be laid side by side.


The first is that values have a history. The lesson on master and slave morality showed that good and evil are not eternal facts stamped into the universe. They were made, by particular people under real pressures, and then, across centuries, mistaken for the permanent order of things. What presents itself as the moral law turns out to have a birthday and a birthplace.


The second discovery cuts deeper. There is no absolute standpoint from which anyone could certify a set of values as the true ones. The lesson on perspectivism showed that there is no view from nowhere, no God's-eye vantage above all human interests where the real values could be read off the world like facts. Values are always valued by someone, from somewhere, for the sake of something.


Put those two together and the floor seems to drop out. If values were merely invented, and if there is no cosmic authority to rank them, then surely they are worthless, arbitrary, nothing at all. This is the exact inference that tips a culture into nihilism: no eternal values, and therefore no values worth the name. It has the feel of plain logic.



The Revaluation of All Values


Nietzsche makes the opposite move, and it is the most important turn in his thought. The step from created values to worthless values, he argues, is a failure of nerve rather than a discovery. It looks compelling only to someone still secretly pining for the old absolutes, someone who keeps measuring every value against the lost God and finding it wanting. Let that longing go, and the same facts read completely differently.


Precisely because values are created rather than found, human beings are free to create them, and to create them well. Were values eternal decrees issued from heaven, a person could only kneel and obey. Because they are human interpretations, the power to make them, and the responsibility for making them, belongs to human beings themselves. The death of God does not abolish value. It relocates the source of value, moving it out of a vacant sky and into the hands of the living, who now have to become the artists of their own valuations whether they want the job or not.


This is the revaluation of all values: the deliberate, clear-eyed creation of new values to replace the ones whose foundation has fallen away. The German word Nietzsche uses, Umwertung, carries the sense of a re-minting, the way a currency gets called in and struck again. Every inherited value is brought to the counter, examined, weighed for what it actually does to the life of the person who carries it, and then revalued or replaced. And this course has met a revaluation once before: the ancient revolt that flipped the old aristocratic values was itself a world-historical re-minting, carried out over centuries, in the dark, with no signature on the work. Nietzsche's project is that same act attempted in the opposite spirit, in daylight, on purpose, with a name signed to it, which is precisely what makes it a task rather than a tide. He considered it the task of his life. The masterwork he planned was to bear the title The Revaluation of All Values, in four volumes, and the notebooks he filled toward it were the same notebooks his sister later mined and stitched into the volume she called The Will to Power, described in the lesson on his life. Of the four volumes, only the first was ever written; collapse took him before the rest. But the charge the project issues is plain enough: the making of values is human work, and there is no more serious work than that.



Life-Affirming and Life-Denying Values


A hard question presses in at once. If the old values are gone and human beings are to mint new ones, by what standard? Create new values sits perilously close to invent whatever pleases you, which would land straight back in the arbitrariness that looked like nihilism a page ago. Nietzsche is not saying that. He has a standard, and it runs through nearly everything he wrote.


The measure is life. Nietzsche judges a value by what it does to the living creature that holds it, whether it expresses strength, growth, and an ascending, thriving life, or whether it springs from weakness and turns against life itself. He sorts values, broadly, into two great kinds. Life-affirming values say yes to this world, to the body, to earthly existence itself, with all its striving and danger and change. Life-denying values do the reverse. They treat this life as a mistake or a sentence to be served, and point away from it toward some truer world elsewhere, a heaven, an afterlife, some realm of pure being where the mess of living is finally left behind.


His charge against much of traditional morality, developed in the lesson on master and slave morality, is that it has been quietly life-denying, born of resentment against a world its makers felt too weak to bear and then dressed up as the highest good. The revaluation turns that around. Of every value it asks a blunt question, almost physiological, a question about the health of the organism holding it: does this make a person larger or smaller, stronger or weaker, more able to affirm existence or less able. The values that pass are to be kept and deepened. The ones that fail, however holy they have grown, are to be revalued down. This is the same measure that lets perspectivism prefer more eyes to fewer, and it is the seed of the yes-saying life that the lesson on amor fati draws out in full.



The Philosophy of the Future


Nietzsche knew he would not finish this work himself, and he said so. He cast himself not as the builder of the new values but as their herald, the one who saw the crisis coming and called for the people who could meet it. He wrote of philosophers of the future, a new kind of thinker strong enough to create values instead of merely inheriting or cataloging them, free spirits, his name for minds unbound from inherited certainties, able to stand in the open air of a world without absolutes and not be crushed by it. He did not claim to be one of them. He claimed to be the voice crying that they must come.


What he was pointing at was a change in the whole job description of a human being. For most of history, in his telling, people received their values the way they received their native language, absorbing them whole from religion, tradition, and community, and never once suspecting the values could have been otherwise. The revaluation ends that innocence. It asks human beings to take up, consciously and with open eyes, a power they had been using all along without knowing it, the power to decide what is worth living for. That is a heavier freedom than most people want, and Nietzsche understood as much. It is also, in his view, the only freedom worthy of a creature that has outgrown its gods. The making of meaning, once assigned to heaven, becomes the work of human hands. That, for Nietzsche, is not the disaster the word nihilism first threatened. It is the start of the only kind of meaning that was ever really ours to make.



The Value Trial


Now the course cashes a promise it has been making since its second lesson, because the notebook has been assembling a dossier this whole time. One conviction has been tracked across three excavations: circled on the Raised-For Page as the inheritance never argued with, brought to the Foundations Page to have its footing named, and dug on the Genealogy Page for its origin and its beneficiaries. The third question was promised for later, the question of what the value costs, and this is the tool that asks it. The Value Trial is the revaluation of all values scaled to one value and one life, and it runs in five steps.


Four guardrails first, because this is the most powerful tool in the course and power wants handling. One value per trial; re-minting is slow work by design. The standard is life-affirmation, not edginess; discarding something merely because it is old or respectable is the lion cosplaying as the child, and contrarian glee fails the trial's own test. Values shared with a household, a family, or a community get revalued in conversation with the people who share them, never by ambush. And the rule from the audit lesson holds here at double strength: nothing gets demolished tonight. A trial ends in a considered verdict, and considered verdicts take longer than an evening.


  1. Summon the defendant. Fetch the tracked conviction, the one the notebook has been following since the Raised-For Page. The trial works on any value, but it works best on this one, because the dossier is already built.

  2. Read the file. Copy onto the trial page the two findings already made: what the value is resting on, from the footing question, and where it came from and who gained, from the genealogy. A trial without the dossier judges a stranger; with it, the court knows exactly who is standing in the dock and how they got there.

  3. Run the examination. Nietzsche's blunt measure, asked four ways, each answered in writing. What does holding this value make possible in my life? What does it cost me, honestly counted? Does it make me larger or smaller? Does it point me toward this life or away from it? Costs and gifts both get listed in full; a trial that hears only one side is not a trial.

  4. Reach one of three verdicts, not two. Keep and deepen: the value serves life, and here is the quiet beauty of that outcome, because an inherited value that passes the trial stops being an inheritance and becomes a possession, held now for its own demonstrated worth, re-minted at the same denomination. Revalue: the metal is good but the coin needs restriking, as when never put yourself first gets restruck into generosity from strength rather than self-erasure. Or retire: the value fails the measure, and gets released, with gratitude for what it once did or without, but slowly, and with the guardrails in force.

  5. Sign the work. Whatever the verdict produced, write the resulting value as one owned sentence beginning "I hold that...", and date it, and sign beside it. This is the entire difference Nietzsche was pointing at. An unsigned value runs a life from the shadows; a signed one has an author who can stand behind it, revise it, and answer for it. The signature is the moment a value stops happening to a person and starts belonging to one.

Here is the trial run once, in brief. Teresa's tracked conviction, circled all the way back on her Raised-For Page, is never be a burden to anyone. The file shows its footing, a devout and overworked childhood household, and its genealogy, a house where the adults were drowning and a child's neediness genuinely cost them, so the value once protected real people. The examination is where it turns. What it makes possible: she is reliable, generous, the one everyone calls. What it costs, honestly counted: she has not asked for help in eleven years, hid a surgery from her own sister, and is quietly exhausted in a way nobody is allowed to see. Larger or smaller: smaller, and shrinking. Toward life or away: away, because a rule against ever weighing on anyone is, followed to its end, a rule against being fully among people at all. Verdict: revalue. The metal is good, the coin restruck: carry your weight, and let yourself be carried, because being carried sometimes is what people are for. And the signature: I hold that giving and receiving help are the same virtue seen from two sides. Teresa, dated. That sentence took her forty years and one trial to own, and it is hers now in a way the original never was.



The Philosopher's Notebook: The Mint Page


Title a fresh page The Mint Page, and let it hold the trial in full: the defendant, the copied file, the four examinations, the verdict, and the signed sentence at the bottom, dated. This page is the notebook's centerpiece, the place where three earlier pages converge and become an act instead of an archive.

And leave room beneath the signature, because minting is a practice, not an event. Values re-minted this year get re-examined in other years; signed sentences get revised by their author, which is the author's right and the whole point of having one. The final lesson of this course gathers the signed work on this page into something larger, so keep it where it can be found.



Below is a practice you can start using in your daily life right away. Like everything here, it’s educational, kept intentionally light, and entirely optional. You remain in charge of your own experience, so adjust, pause, or skip anything that doesn’t feel right for you.



Philosopher's Practice: The Re-Minting


This week's practice runs the trial, tests the tool's edge on something smaller, and takes the standard out into the world.


  1. Run the Value Trial in full on the tracked conviction: dossier copied, all four examinations answered, verdict reached under the guardrails, sentence signed and dated on the Mint Page. Give it a quiet hour, and let the verdict sit for two days before treating it as final; a verdict that survives the second look is the one that counts.

  2. Run one small trial on a value of choice. Pick something lighter, a rule about money, work, manners, rest, and run only the examination and the verdict, steps three to five. This shows the tool works without a full dossier, and it shows why the dossier deepens it, which is worth one written line of comparison.

  3. Walk the world with the standard for a week. Values are on sale everywhere, in ads and feeds, on hustle slogans and wellness posters, and the field exercise is to catch two of them and sort each in two lines on a Field Notes page: what this value promises, and whether it points the person holding it toward life or away from it. No purchases necessary; the exercise is the noticing, and the standing rule from earlier fieldwork applies, observation only, nobody gets corrected at dinner.

  4. Mark the Rumor Page if it has earned it. "Nietzsche tore everything down and offered nothing in its place" is a durable tenant, and this lesson is the eviction: the building project was the point of the demolition, and the trial on the Mint Page is its floor plan at human scale. Evidence sentence required, as always.

With this, the standing kit is complete on the teaching side. What remains for the course is the strange book Nietzsche poured all of it into, and then the gathering of everything the notebook now holds.

Because there is one thing this course has described repeatedly and never yet opened: the book Nietzsche considered his masterpiece and his gift to humanity, the one written like a scripture, starring a prophet who walks down a mountain carrying most of the ideas this course has taught and discovers, scene after scene, that nobody wants them. It is the strangest great book in philosophy, it is where the Übermensch and the Last Man, the three metamorphoses, and the heaviest weight all actually live, and it comes with its own way of being read. Next lesson, the mountain.



Disclaimer

Everything IFS Academy is an independent educational platform and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or connected to the IFS Institute. While we strive for accuracy, errors can occur, and users are encouraged to cross-reference critical information. These courses present the ideas of historical philosophers for educational and self-reflection purposes only. They describe what these thinkers taught and argued and do not constitute an endorsement of any philosophical position, nor do they constitute religious instruction or professional advice of any kind. They do not constitute therapy, mental health treatment, clinical training, or crisis support, and they should not be used as a substitute for professional mental health care.


Crisis Support 🚨

If you are experiencing a mental health crisis, feel unsafe, feel at risk of harming yourself or someone else, or feel too overwhelmed to safely use self-directed practices, please pause this material and reach out for immediate support. Contact a licensed mental health professional, call or text 988 in the U.S. or Canada, or use your local emergency or crisis resources.

 
 
 

Recent Posts

See All
⚡Friedrich Nietzsche | Free Course

A free course by Everything IFS Academy on Friedrich Nietzsche: twelve lessons that hand back the most quoted and least understood philosopher, un-hijacked. Meet the frail invalid behind the roaring p

 
 

Comments


Commenting on this post isn't available anymore. Contact the site owner for more info.

Everything IFS Academy

bottom of page