👻Module 6: Open and Closed: Cultural Responsibility in Deity Work | Deities, Ancestors, and Spirit Allies Course
Updated: Sep 29
Free Course by Everything IFS Academy Witchcraft Series
Help us reach the people who may need this most by sharing this free course with friends, family, colleagues, online communities, social media or on your own website.
🎧 Audio – listen on the go - (coming soon)
Module 6: Open and Closed: Cultural Responsibility in Deity Work
This is the conversation modern witchcraft avoided for a long time, and the avoidance cost something on every side. It cost the communities whose practices were taken without invitation: taken, repackaged, sold, performed by people who did not belong and did not bother to find out. The craft itself paid too, treated less seriously by the wider world every time it appeared in public looking like a costume assembled from other people’s sacred things. And the takers themselves paid, ending up with practices thin where they could be deep, scattered where they could be rooted, built on a foundation that quietly will not hold weight; rot in a foundation eventually reaches the upper rooms.
The word at the center of the conversation is appropriation, so let it be defined plainly before it does any work: appropriation is taking a practice, object, or sacred figure out of the community it belongs to, without invitation, and using it as one’s own. Its opposite number, which this module also teaches, is appreciation: studying, honoring, and supporting a tradition without taking from it. The line between them is real, and one of the promises of this lesson is that an honest witch can learn to see it clearly. Not having this conversation never made the problem disappear; it just let each new generation of beginners absorb the same patterns from the same books and feeds. So this module names the matter directly and gives the working answers a witch actually needs: the map of open and closed, the honest swaps for the most common borrowings, and a five-question tool you’ll carry into every shop and every source for the rest of your practice. Longer academic arguments exist for whoever eventually wants them; the working answer is what serves you at the shop counter and the altar.
The Basic Distinction: Open and Closed
Two more words need plain definitions first, because the whole distinction stands on them. Initiation is formal entry into a tradition, conferred by someone already inside it who has the standing to bring a new person in. A lineage is the living chain of practitioners through whom a tradition has been handed down, teacher to student, generation to generation. With those in hand, the map is simple.
An open tradition welcomes outside practitioners. No initiatic gate must be passed, and no teaching is restricted by ancestry or membership; the deities and practices of such a tradition can be approached, with respect and study, by anyone drawn to them. The Greek and Roman traditions are open. So are most strands of the Celtic and the Norse, and the Slavic and Baltic traditions. A witch pulled toward Hecate or Brigid or Freyja or Inanna needs no one’s permission beyond her own willingness to do the work seriously; the traditions that gave us those names did not lock the door behind them.
A closed tradition is a different thing. It has a defined community, commonly requires initiation by someone carrying the lineage, and holds practices and spirit-relationships that belong to that community by ancestry, by survival, by the long preservation of something nearly destroyed and kept alive at great cost. Such practices cannot be legitimately accessed from outside without being invited in by the tradition itself, on the tradition’s own terms. Reading a book about them grants no access, and neither does watching videos nor self-initiating in one’s bedroom. The gate is where the gate is, and crossing without invitation is not crossing; it is climbing the fence and pretending one was let in.
Which traditions are closed? The Yoruba-derived religions of the African diaspora, diaspora meaning the communities carried out of a homeland and scattered abroad, in this case through the violence of enslavement: Santería, also called Lucumí, Candomblé, Vodou, and their wider family. The orishas and the lwa are not free-floating deities available for borrowing; they belong to communities, lineages, and initiations with specific structures, entered only through the proper doors. Hoodoo, the Black American folk tradition, is closed in its full form, though it has been widely and wrongly treated otherwise by outsiders. Most Indigenous American spiritual traditions are closed, belonging to specific tribal nations that survived deliberate attempts at their destruction. Traditional Jewish mysticism, the Kabbalah, is held within Jewish practice and closed to non-Jews; note, for the sake of the reading you’ll someday do, that the Western occult world long ago built its own separate offshoot, usually spelled Qabalah with a Q, which is its own open Western system and should never be confused with the Jewish original. And some Hindu tantric lineages are closed to anyone not initiated by their living teachers.
Why a Closed Tradition Is Closed
It’s worth saying clearly why closure exists, because “closed” sometimes gets heard as exclusion in a small or petty way, as if these communities simply disliked outsiders. That is not the shape of the matter. A closed tradition is closed because its practices belong to that community, and often because they were preserved through survival itself: through slavery, colonization, forced conversion, and outright violence aimed at erasing the tradition from the earth. They came through. Specific people kept them alive at terrible cost across generations, and the structures that carried them, the initiations, the lineages, the relationships with specific spirits, were shaped by and for those communities. Removed from that context, the practices do not translate; a rite that requires its community in order to function does not become something else when an outsider performs it. It becomes a hollow gesture that sometimes resembles the original from the outside.
So respecting closure is respecting the tradition. A culture choosing to keep something sacred to itself is not being unkind; it is being sovereign, exercising the right to decide what belongs inside the community and what does not. And the witch who hears that a tradition is closed and feels personally rejected has misunderstood what she was told. Nothing has been taken from her. She has simply been informed that something does not belong to her, which is true of nearly everything in the world.
The Middle Zone
The binary of open and closed does not always hold cleanly, and honest teaching says so. Hinduism is the clearest case. It is not a closed initiatic tradition in the way the diasporic religions are; it is a living global religion of over a billion people, worshipping in continuous lineages thousands of years old, and that fact alone makes casual approach inappropriate. A witch reaching for Kali or Saraswati or Lakshmi is not lifting figures from an ancient shelf; she is reaching toward deities currently worshipped by enormous living communities, with established ways those deities are approached, honored, and offended. The right road, for the witch genuinely drawn here, is the slow one: learn from living Hindu teachers, read Hindu sources rather than New Age summaries of them, and understand the specific tradition within Hinduism a deity belongs to before doing anything elaborate.
Kemetic practice sits in its own middle place, exactly as the pantheon tour told you: a sincere modern community rebuilding Egyptian religion from the sources, most of it holding the path open to any respectful comer who does the work, some voices arguing for more guardedness, and both camps agreed that the system does not reduce to picking a deity from a book. Celtic paganism is open in its broad strokes, no gate bars an outsider from Brigid or the Morrigan, yet specific modern Celtic reconstructionist communities keep their own standards about casual use, and a witch entering that territory does well to learn them. The principle for the whole middle zone is one sentence: when in doubt, find the living practitioners and ask what they think. The internet has made that an afternoon’s work, and unwillingness to spend the afternoon is itself a kind of answer about what’s going on in the practitioner.
The Famous Borrowings, and Their Honest Swaps
A handful of practices have been misused so widely in the modern witchcraft space that they deserve naming one by one, each with the better alternative already in your hands. None of the swaps costs a witch anything; they keep her practice cleaner and leave the source traditions in their rightful place.
White sage and “smudging.” Smudging is a specific ceremonial practice of Indigenous American nations, and white sage is one of its sacred plants. Its commercial spread has harmed the source communities and the plant itself, which is now overharvested for the wellness market, including poaching from wild and Indigenous lands. The swap is easy and complete: cleanse with smoke from herbs of your own inheritance, rosemary, mugwort, juniper, garden sage, bay, lavender, pine, or frankincense on charcoal, and call the practice what it plainly is, smoke cleansing. One caution inside the swap: cedar and sweetgrass sometimes appear on alternative lists, and both are themselves sacred plants of specific Indigenous nations; the herbs of your own lines serve better.
Palo santo. Sacred wood of specific South American traditions, now sold in every metaphysical shop, with rising demand putting real conservation pressure on the trees. The same smoke-cleansing swap covers it entirely.
Dreamcatchers. Taken from specific Indigenous nations, where they carry particular meaning, and turned into generic decor. A witch wanting protective craft over her bed has her own traditions’ charms to make instead, and making one is better practice anyway.
Chakras as color-coded clip art. The chakra system belongs to Hindu and related Indian traditions, with depth and context the wellness poster versions strip away. The honest options are two: study the system in actual Hindu sources and use it with its context, or work with the energy frameworks of Western practice instead. What’s declined is only the shallow middle.
“Spirit animal.” A term pulled from specific Indigenous frameworks where it carries real meaning, then flattened into favorite-animal-as-aesthetic. Say what you actually mean: the animal I feel kinship with, my familiar, the bird that keeps appearing in my dreams. Your own experience described in your own words is always yours.
Your Tool: The Provenance Audit
Here is the method this whole module folds down into, five questions a witch asks before adopting any practice, tool, term, or deity. Provenance simply means where a thing comes from and how it reached your hands. You already keep one of these questions as the standing seventh item on your deity-research checklist; this is the full instrument behind it, and it takes five minutes once the habit forms. Ask, ideally in your notebook the first few times:
Where does this actually come from? Not what the packaging or the video says; what the tradition of origin actually is. If you can’t answer, that’s not a small gap, it’s the first finding.
Is that tradition open, closed, or in the middle? Use the map from this module, and where the map runs out, spend the honest afternoon finding what living practitioners of the source tradition say.
Who profits, and who pays? Follow the object or trend to its consequences: does buying this support the source community, or strangers selling their sacred things? Does demand harm a plant, a place, a people? The white sage story is the template for this question.
What does my own inheritance offer instead? Nearly every borrowed practice has a counterpart in the open traditions or in your own lines: a cleansing herb, a protective charm, an energy framework, a deity holding the same territory. Finding the counterpart usually deepens the practice; familiar ground grows deeper roots.
If I’m still unsure, can I wait? The answer is yes. Nothing in this craft spoils while a witch spends a week finding out. Restraint under uncertainty is not timidity; it is the exact muscle integrity is made of.
Watch it work at the shop counter, where the working answer earns its keep. A “beginner witch bundle” sits by the register: white sage, palo santo, a little card of instructions. Question one: Indigenous American and South American sacred plants. Two: closed practice and pressured plants both. On the third, who profits and who pays: the seller profits, while the source communities and the wild stands pay. The fourth turns up garden sage and rosemary growing in the yard, and the family always did say rosemary keeps a house kind. And the fifth never even gets asked; the bundle goes back on the shelf, and the witch walks out with a jar of garden sage and a practice that’s wholly her own. Total time: the length of standing in line.
When a Deity From a Closed Tradition Seems to Call
Now the harder question, the one that arrives unbidden in the practice of many sincere witches. What if the dreams are of an orisha, and won’t stop? What if a lwa appears in vision after vision, with all the persistence and unsought specificity you learned to take seriously in the lesson on callings? The signs may pass every test the ledger can run, and the tradition is still closed. What then?
The consistent answer from teachers within those traditions, given across decades of being asked, is this: seek the tradition itself, on its terms. If the call is real, the practitioner finds her way to the actual community, the teacher, the proper door; real calls, in this telling, open real doors. And if no door opens, no community welcomes, no teacher takes her on, the experienced counsel reads that too. It may be a test of respect, measuring whether she will honor the closure or crash it. It may be her own longing, dressed in a figure she has been romanticizing. Or it may be a signal pointing home: many of the figures that draw Western witches from closed traditions have counterparts in the open ones, powers holding the same territory who may answer the actual longing better than the borrowed name did. Your own inheritance question from the audit does that looking.
What the witch does not do is plainer still. Self-initiation is not on the table, and neither is practicing the closed tradition privately outside its community, and neither is deciding the rules bend because her connection feels strong. Strength of feeling is not the criterion; many people have felt strongly drawn to things that were not theirs. The willingness to accept that one’s feelings do not override another community’s sovereignty is part of what builds the integrity that makes any spiritual practice real.
Building a Practice With Integrity
The whole module folds down once more, into principles simple enough to carry without a list in hand. Begin, when possible, with your own ancestral heritage; there is real ease in traditions the bones half-remember, and practice deepens faster on familiar ground. Where heritage is unclear, complicated, or simply doesn’t pull, the open traditions hold more than enough for several lifetimes.
When uncertain whether something is closed, research; when still uncertain, ask living practitioners, who are findable and generally more willing to answer good-faith questions than the worried beginner expects; and when in doubt after all of that, err on the side of restraint. The craft is old and deep. No witch needs to take from a closed tradition to have a powerful practice, and the notion that the most exotic option must be the most potent one is the wellness market talking, never the actual logic of the work.
Appreciation Is Not Appropriation
One final distinction, held clearly, because the witch who takes this module seriously sometimes overcorrects into a frozen avoidance: afraid to study anything beyond her own narrow inheritance, afraid even to read about traditions she will never practice. That is not the goal, and it is not what the principle asks.
Appreciation is not appropriation. A witch who studies a tradition with genuine seriousness, reads its sacred texts, learns its history, supports its communities, attends what is open to outsiders, and follows its scholars and elders is appreciating that tradition, and nothing in that is taking. Reading a careful book about Vodou is not appropriation. Learning the history of the orishas as part of an education in the world’s religions is not appropriation, and neither is putting money or support behind the communities themselves. The line runs between studying-and-respecting and taking-and-performing: the witch who reads about Santería and honors what she learned by not practicing it has done something honorable, while the one who reads the same book and sets up an orisha altar has crossed the line the book itself, read carefully, was drawing. The line is real, and it is not so subtle that an honest witch cannot see it. A witch does not take what she has not been given; the open doors are open, the closed doors are closed, and there is more than enough behind the open ones for the deepest practice a lifetime can build.
Witch Practice: The Gentle Audit
This week the audit turns homeward, and one thing should be said before it does: every witch who runs this finds something. Every single one, including those with decades in the craft, because we all absorbed the same books and feeds before anyone taught us better. Finding something is not a mark against you; the finding is the practice. So, gently:
Walk your own territory with the five questions. Your devotional space, your supplies drawer, your cleansing habits, and your vocabulary, the words you’d use to describe your practice to a friend. Run anything uncertain through the provenance audit, and list your findings on a fresh notebook page titled “Provenance,” without commentary and without apology. Flat, honest lines: what it is, where it’s actually from, open or closed or unsure.
Make one swap. Choose the clearest finding and make its honest exchange this week: the language corrected, the herb replaced with one from your own lines, the item respectfully retired. Retiring, for a sacred object of a closed tradition, means putting it away from use with a word of acknowledgment, not performing a ceremony over it and not binning it carelessly. One swap, done fully, teaches more than ten planned.
Do one act of appreciation. Balance the subtraction with an addition: one genuine act toward a tradition you respect but will not practice. Read a chapter by one of its own voices, learn the real history of one practice you’ve seen sold, or put support behind one of its organizations. Log what you chose and one sentence on what it taught you.
Close with the inheritance line. Finish the page with one first-person reflection: what did my own inheritance turn out to offer that I’d been reaching past? Date it. That sentence, in the experience of many witches who’ve run this audit, is where the module’s real gift turns up.
And with that, the deity teachings of this course stand complete: the call, the pantheons, the giving, and the honest boundaries around all of it. Next the course crosses to the second great door from your very first map, the one that was never locked to anyone: the dead who are yours. Who the ancestors actually are, why witches have always tended them, and what that tending looks like when it’s real.
Disclaimer: Everything IFS Academy is an independent educational platform and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or connected to the IFS Institute. While we strive for accuracy, errors can occur, and users are encouraged to cross-reference critical information. The courses in the Witchcraft & Folk Magic Series explore witchcraft, folk magic, and related spiritual and cultural practices for educational and personal-interest purposes only. Nothing in them guarantees any particular result, and no ritual, spell, correspondence, or practice is offered as a substitute for professional medical, psychological, legal, or financial advice. Practices that involve fire, candles, herbs, plants, or other physical materials carry real risks such as burns, allergic reaction, or toxicity, and any practice is undertaken at your own discretion and risk. They do not constitute therapy, mental health treatment, clinical training, or crisis support, and they should not be used as a substitute for professional mental health care.
Crisis Support: 🚨 If you are experiencing a mental health crisis, feel unsafe, feel at risk of harming yourself or someone else, or feel too overwhelmed to safely use self-directed practices, please pause this material and reach out for immediate support. Contact a licensed mental health professional, call or text 988 in the U.S. or Canada, or use your local emergency or crisis resources.
Comments