🌐 Module 6 — Thinking Like Hierocles: The Lens in Everyday Life | Hierocles Course
Updated: Sep 6
Free Course by Everything IFS Academy | Stoicism Series
Help us reach the people who may need this most by sharing this free course with friends, family, colleagues, online communities, social media or on your own website.
🎧 Audio is read by AI
Module 6 — Thinking Like Hierocles: The Lens in Everyday Life
Almost everyone carries a quiet argument with themselves about this. On one side, the pull to look after oneself: to rest, to guard one's time, to take the opportunity that is good for one's own life. On the other, the pull to show up for other people, to give, to put someone else first. The two feel like rivals. Choosing the self feels selfish and leaves a residue of guilt. Choosing others feels noble but leaves a residue of resentment, the slow sense of being used up. Most people spend a lifetime sliding back and forth along that line, hunting for the balance point between selfish and selfless, as though a life were a fixed quantity to be divided between oneself and everyone else.
Hierocles' philosophy, taken as a whole, says the line is drawn in the wrong place. Worse than that: it says the line was never really there.
One Motion, Not Three Ideas
It is tempting to file what Hierocles taught as three separate doctrines: a theory of how self-concern begins, a diagram of widening circles, and a list of duties. Held that way, they look like three subjects that happen to share an author. Seen rightly, they are not three things at all. They are one motion described at three scales.
The motion is appropriation, the process Hierocles called oikeiosis, taught earlier in this course as the engine underneath everything else. It is a single continuous reaching: nature puts a creature on its own side, and that same reaching, never interrupted, extends outward to others. The circles of concern are that one motion drawn as a picture, showing how far the reaching can travel. The appropriate acts are the same motion brought down to the ground, showing what it looks like on an ordinary day with particular people. Engine, picture, practice. One thing, seen from three distances. Once that comes into focus, the philosophy stops being a collection of ideas and becomes a single way of looking, which is what a lens is.
The False War Between Self and Others
The lens does its sharpest work on the very argument the opening described. If self-concern and concern for others are one continuous motion rather than two opposed forces, then the war between selfish and selfless was a mistake from the start.
The mistake lives in a picture of the self as a sealed unit, a closed circle with its own good walled off inside it, so that anything spent on others is subtracted from what is mine. Hierocles' account denies the wall. The self that nature hands a person, fully understood, is a social self, the self of a rational creature built to live among others. On that view there is no clean border where one's own good ends and the good of others begins, because caring for others is not a withdrawal from one's own nature but the exercise of it. The same nature that makes a person his own is the nature that binds him to others. To complete the self is to reach past it.
This does not mean conflicts of interest never happen. They plainly do. Two people can want the one seat, the scarce job, the last of something, and no philosophy dissolves that. What the lens dissolves is the larger framing, the notion that a whole human life is a zero-sum trade between self and world, with every gift to another booked as a loss to oneself. That framing, Hierocles' thought suggests, misdescribes what a good human life even is. A flourishing life is not one that finds the right ratio of selfishness to sacrifice. It is one in which the question loses its grip, because a person has come to count the good of others as genuinely part of his own.
The Distance Dial
Carried into ordinary life, the lens makes one feature of experience suddenly visible: concern comes with a kind of distance dial. It runs warm toward what is near and cools toward what is far, and most people never notice the dial at all, mistaking its default setting for a fixed law about how much anyone can be expected to care.
The whole of Hierocles' thought is the discovery that the dial can be turned. That reframes two things at once. The distant stranger stops being nothing and becomes simply someone set far out, a person who could be drawn nearer rather than a permanent fixture of the cold edge. And the near people, the ones already close, stop being the easy part and become the main event, the first and realest field where the turning actually happens. A man named Devon can hold the loftiest feelings about humanity in the abstract and still be curt with the people in his own house, and the lens names that for exactly what it is: the dial turned up where it costs nothing and left low where it would cost something. The real work is rarely with the faraway. It is with the people close enough to be difficult.
A Lens Built for This Age
It is worth noticing how precisely this old idea fits a world Hierocles could not have imagined. The modern condition is, in a sense, the distance dial under enormous strain.
Screens deliver distant suffering at a volume no ancient Roman ever faced: famines, wars, and disasters arriving all day from every corner of the earth, far more than any human heart was built to hold. The natural result is the cooling everyone knows, the scroll past the catastrophe, the numbness that feels like a personal defect and is closer to plain overload. At the same time, the sorting of people into tribes and sides pushes the outer rings further out, hardening strangers into opponents. Hierocles offers no trick for this, and it would be dishonest to pretend a person can feel a distant famine the way they feel a flat tire. Performing that feeling is its own kind of falseness. What the lens offers instead is a direction. It holds that concern is naturally narrow, that this is not a sin but a starting point, and that it can be widened on purpose, toward the people one can actually reach. In an age built to scatter attention thin across everything and deep into nothing, a teaching about the patient, chosen widening of concern is not a relic. It is oddly exact.
The Work Is the Direction
One last thing belongs to the lens, and it is the part most easily lost. The Stoics did not regard this as a project a person completes. The circles are never fully drawn in. No one arrives at a finished state of universal concern and sets the work down for good.
That is not a flaw in the philosophy. It is the heart of it. The Stoics held philosophy to be lifelong training, a daily practice rather than a destination, and Hierocles' widening of the circles is exactly that kind of practice: never done, returned to each morning, measured not by arrival but by direction. The question his whole body of work leaves a person with is not whether the outermost circle has been reached, which it never finally is. It is a smaller and harder question, available every day: which way is the concern moving, drawing people inward where more of them become real, or letting them drift back out to the cold edge where they thin into strangers again. A life spent turning the dial the right way, knowing the turning is never finished, is what it means to think like Hierocles.
Below this lesson, you'll find a practice built around one of the teachings you just explored, along with a few ways to begin noticing it in everyday life this week.
Disclaimer:
Everything IFS Academy is an independent educational platform and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or connected to the IFS Institute. While we strive for accuracy, errors can occur, and users are encouraged to cross-reference critical information. These courses present the ideas of historical Stoic philosophers for educational and self-reflection purposes only. They describe what these thinkers taught and argued and do not constitute an endorsement of any philosophical position, nor do they constitute religious instruction or professional advice of any kind. They do not constitute therapy, mental health treatment, clinical training, or crisis support, and they should not be used as a substitute for professional mental health care.
Crisis Support: 🚨
If you are experiencing a mental health crisis, feel unsafe, feel at risk of harming yourself or someone else, or feel too overwhelmed to safely use self-directed practices, please pause this material and reach out for immediate support. Contact a licensed mental health professional, call or text 988 in the U.S. or Canada, or use your local emergency or crisis resources.
Comments